The Harrogate and Knaresborough Area Constituency Committee met this morning meeting. Congestion on Wetherby Road and Skipton Road, and the otley Road cycle route, were among the topics discussed.

• The 15-person committee, which is controlled by the Liberal Democrats, advises North Yorkshire County Council, which is controlled by the Conservatives.


• Today's agenda included 20mph speed limits, Harrogate transport improvements, climate change and culture.


• You can watch the meeting here.

Here's what happened.

---

12.31pm: 'Nightmare’ and ‘flawed’: Harrogate’s Otley Road cycle path under further fire

A lively debate about the Otley Road cycle path took place at today's meeting. You can read a full report of the discussion here.

---

12.22pm: Culture report criticised

A lengthy report on a cultural framework for North Yorkshire is widely criticised by all parties for having 'gaps' and not consulting enough with groups in Harrogate and Knaresborough.

The report cost £20,000 of which £10,000 came from the county council and £10,000 from Arts Council England.

---

11.50pm: Call for congestion action on Wetherby Road and Skipton Road

Liberal Democrat leader Pat Marsh (pictured left) questions the focus on Leeds Road. She says the busiest roads are Wetherby Road and Skipton Road. She adds: "It's chronic. How are you going to introduce safe cycling?"

Talking about Wetherby Road, she adds: "The traffic tails back so far it's unbelievable. It's there day and night. Why that road is not being looked at, I do not know."

Cllr Marsh adds there is also potential for a park and ride at the Great Yorkshire Showground just off Wetherby Road.

She then suggests building a new secondary school in the New Park area. "Harrogate's secondary schools are all on the same side of town."

Green councillor Arnold Warneken says it took him 40 minutes to drive from the Kestrel roundabout to today's meeting at the council office at Knapping Mount.

Liberal Democrat Philip Broadbank expresses exasperation at the slow speed at which active travel schemes progress. "There is so much consultation."

The officer's report is merely 'noted', after numerous protests of frustration at the rate of change.

---

11.40pm: Call for action on Harrogate transport schemes

Conservative councillor Paul Haslam says "I'd like to see more action rather than more process" after an officer gives an update on phase two of the Harrogate Transport Improvement Programme.

The officer says the programme is an evolution of the Harrogate Congestion Study, which received more than 15,000 responses in 2020 and showed support for a park and ride bus service plus more active travel. The A61 Leeds Road was identified as the area for potential of the greatest improvements.

The officer says work on the second phase began in July, and she expects to have further details by end of 2022, promoting Cllr Haslam to say the issue is getting bogged down by process.

He also says a train station at Claro Road would ease traffic congestion.

---

11.15 Call for pilot 20mph zone approved

Nine vote in favour, two against and one abstain from Cllr Warneken's motion to introduce a 20mph pilot.

But that doesn't mean it will happen - it will now go to the county council executive, which will decide whether to act on the outcome.

---

11.01 Should there be a pilot 20mph scheme?

Green councillor Arnold Warneken calls for a pilot 20mph scheme. Several councillors speak in favour of reducing speed limits but Cllr Michael Harrison, a Conservative, says he is against it.

He says he admires the 20's Plenty campaign for trying but says enforcement and capital spend are problems. He says there are highways issues in his division that have been hanging around for a while, which he would prefer to see dealing with.

---

10.53am £1m cost of implementing 20mph limits

Asked how much introducing 20mph limits would cost, council officer says the figure would be "looking at something north of a million pounds", and would take at least 12 to 18 months to implement.

---

10.43am: Call for default 20mph speed limit

Cycling campaigner Malcolm Margolis (pictured) is reading a statement on behalf of 20's Plenty calling for a default 20mph speed limit in towns and villages in Harrogate and Knaresborough.

A council officer says the county council recognises the benefits 20mph limits can bring and wants to make the roads as safe as possible and will continue to consider all options.

---

10.30am: Parish councillor calls for 'kick up the backside'  

Councillor Howard West of Pannal and Burn Bridge Parish Council says nothing in the Harrogate Transport Improvements Programme, a report which is due to be discussed today, satisfies residents that plans are in place to prevent 'gridlock' in Harrogate's western arc when thousands of new homes are built.

He says the council should "shelve the Maltkiln survey" until it has solved what's happening now in the west of Harrogate. Cllr West said today's recommendation is to 'note the report', adding:

"Our recommendation is for members to effect the equivalent of a kick up the backside and for meaningful action to get immediate results now rather than for procrastination and excuses."

---

10.21am: Cycling group's frustration over cycling schemes

Kevin Douglas, chair of Harrogate District Cycling Action, expresses concerns about the slow pace of the various cycling schemes.

The council officer says: "We accept there has been a delay" on the Otley Road scheme and cites "numerous design issues". She adds consultation on phase two of the scheme is "due imminently".

She also says plans public engagement on new plans for Oatlands Drive are "due to start this month".

---

10.07am: Residents' group criticises 'nightmare' Otley Road cycle path.

A statement is read by a members of Harrogate and Pannal Ash Residents' Association saying consultation with residents about the Otley Road cycle path had uncovered comments such as it being "fundamentally flawed", "a nightmare", "an accident waiting to happen".

He asks for a full, meaningful and proper consultation for the remainder of the Otley Road scheme "before designs are firmed up". he adds:

"The general feeling is the scheme will do v little, if anything to offset the huge housing growth for thew west of Harrogate."

A council officer says it plans to stage a "meet the designer event to make it possible to have those meaningful conversations going forward".